Hearts and Minds - 1974
Director(s)
Peter Davis
Writer(s)
Producer(s)
Henry Lange producer
Bert Schneider producer
Cast
Georges Bidault - Himself
Clark Clifford - Himself
George Coker - Himself
Kay Dvorshock - Herself (also archive footage)
Daniel Ellsberg - Himself
Randy Floyd - Himself
J. William Fulbright - Himself (as J.W. Fulbright)
Brian Holden -
Robert Muller - Himself
Khanh Nguyen - Himself
Walt Rostow - Himself
William C. Westmoreland - Himself
Chi Minh Ho - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Bob Hope - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Lyndon Johnson - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
John F. Kennedy - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Robert F. Kennedy - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Dinh Diem Ngo - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Ngoc Loan Nguyen - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Van Thieu Nguyen - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Richard Nixon - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
George S. Patton IV - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Thi Kim Phuc Phan - Herself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Ronald Reagan - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Maxwell Taylor - Himself (archive footage) (uncredited)
Review by Jack Gatanella
Hearts and Minds (1974)
This is to the Vietnam War as Bowling for Columbine is to Violence in America,
Peter Davis' Hearts and Minds does it's best to try and get both sides of the issue on America's military involvement in Vietnam, and like Bowling for Columbine the film can be accessible to an audience on each side of the coin (though with this film Davis isn't in front of the camera at all). This is perfectly filmed in the end credits sequence in which a march is being held for Vietnam veterans while the protesters line the adjacent streets. What makes the film all the powerful is that there isn't a bias going on to either side- while one scene will show a Vietnamese civilian being interviewed about how the devastation from the bombs have ruined his family and home, another will show prisoner of war George Coker explaining things to American children. In the end what gets Hearts and Minds to the level of great documentary filmmaking is that all of the footage of old speeches and old military movies, and all the interviews with various political figures and Vietnamese personnel, all add up to delivering an objective stance for the viewer. The facts of which are presented as such: America went into Vietnam, left their mark, and while America had two sides to the issue so did the Vietnamese, and that's what made the whole deal one of the most controversial topics of the 20th century. Overall, this is an intelligent and compassionate look at the effects of War in general. A+
|
